1987

Only Harvey Kuenn, who used up his 15 years, drops out. Sorry, TJ.

9 Luis Aparicio 6th
1 Sal Bando
2 Paul Blair
1 Bobby Bonds
2 Bernie Carbo
3 Rico Carty
8 Norm Cash
14 Rocky Colavito
5 Mike Cuellar
13 Jim Davenport
3 Willie Davis 8th
3 Dock Ellis
11 Curt Flood
6 Bill Freehan 3rd
4 Jim Fregosi
1 Jerry Grote
2 John Hiller
2 Willie Horton
14 Elston Howard
9 Frank Howard
3 Jim Hunter 7th
14 Larry Jackson
3 Mickey Lolich
14 Roger Maris 4th
1 Mike Marshall
10 Bill Mazeroski
2 Tim McCarver
6 Sam McDowell
6 Dave McNally
3 Thurman Munson 9th
7 Vada Pinson 10th
6 Tony Oliva
2 J.R. Richard
3 George Scott
1 Steve Stone
3 Roy White
10 Maury Wills
4 Wilbur Wood
5 Jim Wynn 5th

Bob’s ballot:

1. Maris
2. Hunter
3. Aparicio
4. Pinson
5. Davis
6. Freehan
7. Mazeroski
8. Bonds
9. Bando
10. Flood

Terry’s ballot:

1: Roger Maris
2: Thurman Munson
3: Luis Aparicio
4: Catfish Hunter
5: Tony Oliva
6: Bobby Bonds
7: Mike Marshall
8: Jim Wynn
9: Elston Howard
10: Bill Freehan

HM
Tim McCarver
Sal Bando

I’m pretty sure I’m whistling up a tree about Marshall, but I think he deserves to be in the Hall of Fame eventually. Had his ideas been respected, rather than mocked, we might not be saddled with 12 and 13 man pitching staffs now.

Results:

14 ballots; the results:

94 Roger Maris
92 Luis Aparicio
************
88 Bill Freehan
76 Bobby Bonds
67 Jim Wynn
63 Jim Hunter
59 Sal Bando
48 Tony Oliva
46 Willie Davis
44 Vada Pinson
39 Thurman Munson
32 Norm Cash
21 Bill Mazeroski
20 Mickey Lolich
11 Wilbur Wood
10 Elston Howard
7 Rocky Colavito
7 Curt Flood
7 Maury Wills
6 Jim Fregosi
5 Mike Cuellar
4 Mike Marshall
2 Paul Blair
2 Larry Jackson
2 Sam McDowell
1 Rico Carty
1 Roy White